Long warranties win on paper. In the Corolla LE size, the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus cost $1.51 per 1,000 warranted miles against $3.72 for the Continental ExtremeContact DWS06 PLUS12. Handling, wet grip and noise are not in this number; read the maker's description of each tire.
Equal prices, different value. In 265/70R17 the Alenza and the Steadfast were both $260.99, but the Alenza's 80,000 mile warranty brings it to $3.26 per 1,000 miles against $3.7334.
All-terrain costs more per mile. The Wildpeak A/T4W was the cheapest 265/70R17 tire per tire, but not per warranted mile5. That is the trade for off-road grip.